13 Untapped Crafts to Make and Sell With Insane Profit Margins
One creator turned $50 in supplies into $12K/month selling a niche craft nobody else touched. These 13 untapped crafts can do the same for you in 2026 — with margins over 500%. If you’re looking for untapped crafts to make and sell, this guide is your goldmine. In a world of saturated markets like candles and soaps, these lesser-known ideas leverage 2026 trends such as personalization, sustainability, and quick digital hybrids to stand out on platforms like Etsy or TikTok Shop. Whether you’re aiming for high profit margin crafts 2026 or profitable crafts to sell Etsy, these beginner-friendly options require minimal skills, low startup costs, and deliver crafts to make money from home with real returns. Think easy crafts with insane margins that turn everyday materials into $30–$200 items. I’ve tested similar side hustles, starting from my kitchen table, and seen profits compound quickly. No fluff—these are actionable, with real math to motivate your launch. Let’s turn your creativity into cash.
1. Custom Pet Portrait Keychains
Material cost per item + total startup: $1.50 per keychain (acrylic blanks $0.50, fine markers $0.50, resin seal $0.50); startup $40 (blanks pack $20, markers $10, resin $10).
Average selling price & profit margin: $15–$25 each; 900–1500% margin after costs.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Pet personalization booms with AI photo tools, but handmade mini-portraits add emotional touch—low competition as most focus on large prints; sustainable with recycled acrylic.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Gather supplies from AliExpress (blanks) and Amazon (markers). 2) Print small pet photo, trace onto blank with markers. 3) Seal with resin for durability (dry 1 hour). 4) Attach keychain ring. 5) List on Etsy with customization option ($5 extra for name). 6) Promote via pet TikTok hashtags.
Scaling tip: Batch 50 at once (2 hours total); offer bundles (3 for $50) for repeat buyers.
Photo description idea: Close-up of colorful hand-drawn dog face on clear acrylic keychain, dangling from keys with “Fido” engraved.
2. Upcycled Bottle Cap Magnets
Material cost per item + total startup: $0.80 per magnet (caps free/recycled, magnets $0.30, glue/paint $0.50); startup $30 (magnets pack $15, craft paint $10, glue $5).
Average selling price & profit margin: $5–$10 each (sets of 6 for $30); 525–1150% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Sustainability trend loves upcycled decor, but bottle cap art with custom themes (e.g., travel icons) is niche—eco-friendly appeal with zero waste materials.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Collect caps from recycling. 2) Paint designs (e.g., mini maps). 3) Glue magnet to back (dry 30 minutes). 4) Package in sets. 5) Sell on Shopify with “zero-waste” tag. 6) Market via Instagram Reels showing process.
Scaling tip: Partner with local bars for free caps; create themed series (e.g., holiday sets) for seasonal boosts.
Photo description idea: Cluster of painted bottle caps as fridge magnets, featuring tiny world landmarks in vibrant colors.
3. Personalized Morse Code Bracelets
Material cost per item + total startup: $2 per bracelet (beads $1, cord $0.50, clasp $0.50); startup $50 (bead assortment $30, cord/clasps $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $20–$40 each; 900–1900% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Personalization via apps, but Morse code messages (e.g., “love” in beads) add secret sentiment—low comp as most jewelry is generic; quick-make for busy creators.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Buy beads/cord from AliExpress. 2) Use Morse chart to string code (e.g., dots/dashes as bead patterns). 3) Secure with clasp. 4) Offer custom words. 5) List on Etsy with decoder card. 6) Promote on Pinterest for sentimental gifts.
Scaling tip: Pre-make popular phrases; use Etsy ads for $50 budget to reach 1K views/month.
Photo description idea: Delicate bracelet with bead pattern spelling “strength” in Morse, on a wrist with inspirational tattoo.
4. Hand-Painted Plant Pots with Quotes
Material cost per item + total startup: $3 per pot (terracotta pot $2, paint $1); startup $40 (pots pack $20, acrylic paint $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $15–$35 each; 400–1067% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Plant boom with urban gardening, but quote-painted pots add motivation—sustainable terracotta appeals to eco-trend, low comp beyond plain pots.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Source pots from Amazon. 2) Paint base color, add quote (e.g., “grow through what you go through”). 3) Seal with varnish (dry 1 hour). 4) Package with care tag. 5) Sell on local markets or Shopify. 6) Use TikTok for painting timelapses.
Scaling tip: Theme series (e.g., motivational, funny)—batch paint 20/week for efficiency.
Photo description idea: Small terracotta pot painted white with black script quote “bloom where planted,” beside succulent.
5. Digital Tarot Card Printables
Material cost per item + total startup: $0 (digital); startup $20 (Canva Pro $20/year, but free tier works).
Average selling price & profit margin: $5–$15 per download; near 100% margin after creation.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Spirituality trend with digital wellness, but customizable tarot designs for printing are niche—hybrid digital for instant delivery, low comp.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Use Canva to design cards (original art to avoid copyright). 2) Create PDF deck. 3) Add personalization option. 4) List on Etsy as digital download. 5) Promote on Pinterest with “print at home” pins. 6) Update seasonally (e.g., zodiac themes).
Scaling tip: Bundle full deck + guide; automate sales with Etsy digital delivery.
Photo description idea: Digital tarot card printout on table, with mystical symbols and “strength” theme in watercolor style.
6. Resin Bookmark Sets
Material cost per item + total startup: $1.50 per bookmark (resin $1, dried flowers $0.50); startup $60 (resin kit $40, molds $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $10–$20 per set of 4; 567–1233% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: BookTok rise boosts reading accessories, but resin with embedded flowers is niche—sustainable with natural elements, quick-make.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Buy kit from Amazon. 2) Mix resin, add flowers in mold. 3) Cure 24 hours (but batch multiple). 4) Package in sets. 5) Sell on Etsy with “nature-inspired” tag. 6) Market via Instagram book communities.
Scaling tip: Offer custom embeds (e.g., birth flowers); produce 50/week for bulk sales.
Photo description idea: Transparent resin bookmark with pressed daisies, lying on open book page.
7. Crochet Amigurumi Keychains
Material cost per item + total startup: $1 per keychain (yarn $0.50, stuffing $0.50); startup $30 (yarn $15, hook $5, rings $10).
Average selling price & profit margin: $8–$15 each; 700–1400% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Kawaii trend with personalization, but mini amigurumi animals are niche—eco-yarn options for sustainability, fast crochet for beginners.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Get yarn/hook from AliExpress. 2) Crochet small animal (30 minutes). 3) Stuff and attach ring. 4) Offer custom colors. 5) List on TikTok Shop for viral potential. 6) Promote with cute videos.
Scaling tip: Pre-make popular animals; kits for DIY add-ons increase value.
Photo description idea: Tiny crocheted fox keychain hanging from bag, with fluffy tail and button eyes.
8. Wire-Wrapped Crystal Pendants
Material cost per item + total startup: $2 per pendant (crystal $1, wire $1); startup $40 (crystals $20, wire/pliers $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $15–$30 each; 650–1400% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Crystal wellness trend, but wire-wrapped with intent (e.g., healing properties) is niche—no tools needed beyond pliers, personalization high.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Source crystals/wire from Amazon. 2) Wrap wire around crystal. 3) Add cord for necklace. 4) Include property card. 5) Sell on Etsy with “energy” keywords. 6) Market via spiritual Instagram.
Scaling tip: Bundle with meanings guide; wholesale crystals for bulk.
Photo description idea: Amethyst crystal wrapped in copper wire as pendant, on simple black cord.
9. Fabric Scrap Quilts for Dolls
Material cost per item + total startup: $1.50 per quilt (scraps free/recycled, thread $0.50, batting $1); startup $25 (thread $10, batting $15).
Average selling price & profit margin: $10–$20 each; 567–1233% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Doll/toy customization with upcycled fabrics ties to sustainability—low comp as most quilts are full-size, quick sew.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Collect scraps from old clothes. 2) Sew mini quilt patches. 3) Add batting, quilt together. 4) Package for doll beds. 5) Sell on local markets or Etsy. 6) Promote as “eco-toys.”
Scaling tip: Use scrap bundles; theme for holidays to boost sales.
Photo description idea: Tiny patchwork quilt in pastels, draped over doll bed with stuffed animal.
10. Scented Wax Melts in Unique Shapes
Material cost per item + total startup: $1 per melt (wax $0.50, scent $0.50); startup $50 (wax $20, molds $20, scents $10).
Average selling price & profit margin: $5–$10 per pack of 6; 400–900% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Aromatherapy trend, but unique shapes (e.g., crystals) add novelty—soy wax for eco, low melt time.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Melt wax from Amazon. 2) Add scent, pour into molds. 3) Cool 1 hour. 4) Package in tins. 5) Sell on Shopify with “mood” sets. 6) Market via scent TikToks.
Scaling tip: Custom scents; subscription packs for repeat.
Photo description idea: Heart-shaped wax melts in lavender, scattered on wooden tray.
11. Leather Cord Organizers
Material cost per item + total startup: $1.50 per organizer (leather scraps $1, snaps $0.50); startup $35 (scraps $15, snaps $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $8–$15 each; 433–900% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Tech accessory demand with minimalism—upcycled leather for sustainability, quick snap assembly.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Cut leather strips from AliExpress scraps. 2) Add snaps. 3) Wrap cords. 4) Personalize with stamps. 5) Sell on Etsy as “tech tidy.” 6) Promote via office Instagram.
Scaling tip: Color varieties; bundles for desks.
Photo description idea: Brown leather wrap holding earbuds, snapped shut neatly.
12. Pressed Flower Phone Cases
Material cost per item + total startup: $2 per case (clear case $1, flowers/resin $1); startup $50 (cases $20, flowers $10, resin $20).
Average selling price & profit margin: $20–$40 each; 900–1900% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Nature aesthetic with personalization—dried flowers for eco, resin seal for durability, low comp.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Press flowers (free from garden). 2) Arrange on case back. 3) Seal with resin (dry 1 hour). 4) Custom flower choices. 5) Sell on TikTok Shop. 6) Market as “botanical tech.”
Scaling tip: Seasonal flowers; kits for DIY add revenue.
Photo description idea: Clear phone case with pressed daisies and lavender embedded.
13. Mini Terrarium Necklaces
Material cost per item + total startup: $2.50 per necklace (glass vial $1, moss/plants $1, chain $0.50); startup $45 (vials $20, moss $15, chains $10).
Average selling price & profit margin: $15–$30 each; 500–1100% margin.
Why it’s untapped/high-margin in 2026: Wearable nature trend with biophilia—sustainable moss, tiny size for quick make, personalization high.
Step-by-step make & sell guide: 1) Fill vial with moss/tiny plants from Amazon. 2) Seal cork. 3) Attach chain. 4) Add care tag. 5) Sell on Etsy as “living jewelry.” 6) Promote via eco TikToks.
Scaling tip: Theme (e.g., zodiac plants); wholesale vials for bulk.
Photo description idea: Small glass vial necklace with green moss and tiny fern, on chain around neck.
Bonus Sections
How to Price for Insane Profits (Formula)
Price = (Material Cost x 2) + (Time Cost at $20/hour) + 50% Markup for Profit. Example: $2 cost + $5 time (15 min) = $7 base; add 50% = $10.50—round to $15 for 650% margin. Adjust for platform fees (Etsy 6.5%).
Best Platforms to Sell in 2026
Etsy: For handmade, 20% fees but high traffic—use for personalization. Shopify: Own store, $29/month—integrate TikTok Shop for viral sales. Local markets: Low fees, direct cash—start for feedback. TikTok Shop: Video demos, low entry—leverage for 2026 trends.
Free Craft Profit Calculator Printable
DIY spreadsheet: Columns for Craft Name, Material Cost/Item, Time/Item, Selling Price, Units Sold, Total Profit. Add formula for margin % = ((Price – Cost) / Cost) x 100. Print monthly—track to hit $1K/month goal.
FAQs – Untapped Crafts to Make and Sell
What crafts have the highest profit margins? Digital tarot printables—near 100% after creation, scalable infinitely.
Can beginners make money selling crafts? Yes—with low-startup like bottle cap magnets, practice 10 items first.
Best money saving hacks for craft supplies 2026? AliExpress bulk buys—save 50% vs. retail.
Clever ways to sell crafts online? TikTok Shop videos—viral potential for untapped niches.
Hidden money saving tips for shipping? Use recycled packaging—cut costs 30%, appeal to eco-buyers.
Smart money saving tricks for marketing? Pinterest free pins—drive Etsy traffic without ads.
Everyday money saving hacks for craft business? Batch production—save time 50%, reduce material waste.
Profitable crafts to sell Etsy in 2026? Personalized Morse bracelets—customization boosts prices 50%.
Conclusion
Pick one untapped craft, make your first 10 items this weekend, list them — and launch your six-figure side hustle. These 13 ideas prove creativity pays in 2026—your passion awaits profits. Which calls to you? Start creating!
